The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed a lawsuit against Cumberland DRW on Thursday, alleging the crypto market maker acted as an unregistered securities dealer. According to the SEC, Cumberland "bought and sold" various cryptocurrencies that the agency classifies as unregistered securities.
The complaint highlights that Cumberland promoted cryptocurrencies such as Polygon's {{POL}} (formerly MATIC), Solana's (SOL), Cosmos' (ATOM), Algorand's (ALGO), and Filecoin's (FIL), identifying them as part of a "non-exhaustive list" of assets sold as securities.
Securities or Investment Contracts?
The SEC’s complaint argues that public statements made by the issuers and promoters of these cryptocurrencies, alongside Cumberland's own communications, suggested that these assets should be viewed as investment contracts under federal securities laws.
The agency pointed out that Cumberland distributed promotional material, including research reports and update emails, which led investors to expect financial returns from these crypto assets.
For instance, the SEC highlighted a February 2023 email from Cumberland promoting Cosmos' ATOM, which stated that the asset had strong fundamentals and a healthy developer community, adding that "we expect to see a catchup rally if crypto remain buoyant." The agency views such statements as encouraging investment in what it considers unregistered securities.
Related reading：Rimar Capital Settles with SEC Over Alleged AI Fraud Scheme
Cumberland Pushes Back
In response, Cumberland maintained that it had no intention of altering its business operations. The firm issued a statement on X (formerly Twitter) asserting confidence in its "strong compliance framework" and its commitment to adhering to all known rules and regulations, despite the SEC's evolving stance on digital assets.
Cumberland's statement also referenced the fluidity of the SEC's position on certain cryptocurrencies, remarking that "it wasn't long ago ETH was claimed to be a security." The company appears to be challenging the SEC's classification of the assets involved in the suit.
Related reading：FTX's repayment plan has caused extreme dissatisfaction among creditors. Large creditors may not receive compensation until the second half of next year
Ongoing Regulatory Tensions
The SEC’s lawsuit against Cumberland is the latest in a series of actions targeting unregistered securities activity within the cryptocurrency market. With its sights set on enforcing federal securities laws in the crypto space, the case underscores the regulatory uncertainty surrounding digital assets.
As the industry continues to grapple with evolving interpretations, the outcome of this suit could have wide-reaching implications for other market participants.
Alex
Joy
Brian
Kikyo
Hui Xin